When the intra-group loan is pledged but the bankrupt debtor wants to set off
Dagens industri has recently reported that the bankruptcy administrator of Northvolt is contesting a claim from a bank syndicate that is based on a pledged intra-group loan. We do not know the details and take no view on the merits. The question is still thought-provoking, because security over intra-group loans is part of most financings we work on. Below we share a few thoughts based on what we typically see.
To give a clear frame, the article turns on three questions. The first is what it means for the right of set-off whether the intra-group loan is documented as a non-negotiable promissory note or an ordinary claim (Sw. enkel fordran) or as a negotiable promissory note (Sw. löpande skuldebrev). The second is to what extent intercreditor or subordination terms and insolvency law can limit or strengthen the right of set-off. The third is which practical choices in structuring, notification and contract drafting matter most for the lenders’ protection in an insolvency.
We deal first with the difference between an ordinary claim and a negotiable note, then with subordination and intercreditor agreements, and we end with the practical consequences for documentation and notification.
The question
When one group company lends to another and the receivable is pledged to the lenders, the lenders expect to be able to enforce that receivable if things go wrong. If the borrower under the intra-group loan has a claim of its own against the lending company, the question is whether the two claims can be set off against each other. If the set-off stands, there is to that extent no pledged receivable left.
Ordinary claim or negotiable note
The Swedish Promissory Notes Act treats a pledge in the same way as a transfer of the claim (Section 10). What then applies depends on the form of the claim.
If the intra-group loan is an ordinary, non-negotiable claim, the pledgee gets no better right than the pledgor had (Section 27). As a main rule the debtor may set off against the pledgee as well. The exception is a counterclaim that the debtor acquired after it learned of the pledge, or that falls due only after that point and later than the main claim (Section 28). What the pledgee knew is irrelevant. What matters is when the counterclaim arose and when it falls due.
In practice the debtor under an intra-group loan is usually itself a party to the finance documents and knows of the pledge from the first day. Counterclaims that build up afterwards through ordinary intra-group flows then typically fall outside the right of set-off, while older ones remain. From the lenders’ perspective an intra-group loan in the form of an ordinary claim therefore carries a real risk that older intra-group counterclaims can be set off against the pledged claim, while a negotiable note normally gives stronger protection against set-off.
If the intra-group loan is a negotiable promissory note, the starting point is the reverse. As a main rule the debtor may not set off against the pledgee. An exception applies if the pledgee, when the note was pledged, knew or should have suspected both that the counterclaim existed and that the debtor would suffer a loss when the right of set-off was lost (Section 18, first paragraph). For a counterclaim arising out of the same legal relationship as the note, a connected counterclaim, the threshold is lower (Section 18, second paragraph). In that case the good faith test that applies to objections arising from the underlying relationship (Section 15) is used instead.
The first test is demanding. It is not enough that the lenders knew that intra-group balances existed. They must also have realised that the debtor risked losing the possibility of being paid for its counterclaim, which in practice requires insight into the pledgor’s weak finances at that time.
The second test covers counterclaims that are closely tied to the transaction behind the note, the textbook example being a buyer’s claim for a price reduction. Such a counterclaim is treated as an objection to the debt itself. It is still lost against a pledgee in good faith, but it is enough that the pledgee knew or should have suspected the circumstance on which the counterclaim is based. The Supreme Court accepted set-off on this basis in NJA 1985 p. 121, where the counterclaims arose from the same agreement as the pledged note.
The same intra-group loan can therefore lead to different outcomes depending on how it is documented. An old counterclaim that the lenders were unaware of can be set off against an ordinary claim but not against a negotiable note. NJA 1997 p. 454 illustrates that the pledgee’s classification does not always prevail. In that case the pledgee was not allowed to rely, as against the debtor, on the instruments having kept their character as negotiable notes. The Supreme Court therefore applied Section 28 of the Promissory Notes Act and accepted set-off.
The subordination terms
Syndicated financings normally include an intercreditor or subordination agreement. In it the group companies undertake not to set off intra-group claims against each other for as long as the lenders are owed money, and the intra-group claims are subordinated to those of the lenders.
If the debtor is bound by such terms, the lenders often do not need to rely on the protection in the Promissory Notes Act. As a starting point a bankruptcy estate has no better right than the company had. If the company has waived set-off outside bankruptcy, set-off is normally excluded in bankruptcy as well. The terms also affect the analysis under the Act, since a party that has already waived its right of set-off loses nothing when the receivable is pledged.
Two further features point the same way. Subordination terms usually treat set-off as a form of payment, so a set-off would give the intra-group claim full recovery ahead of the lenders, contrary to the agreed ranking. They also tend to include a turnover obligation for anything received in breach of the terms.
How far the terms reach depends on their wording, on which companies are party to them and on which claims they cover. They are worth reading with an insolvency in mind already when the financing is put in place.
An administrator can be expected to test these points, in particular whether the company was a party to the agreement in the relevant capacity and whether the claim falls within the definitions. A further question is whether the prohibition by its wording expressly covers insolvency. In a larger structured financing, and without knowing the details in Northvolt, the wording that prohibits set-off will as a general rule also apply after a bankruptcy has occurred.
It is also worth bearing in mind that it is the pledgee that is entitled to receive payment of a pledged claim. In NJA 2000 p. 78 the Supreme Court held that a bankruptcy administrator has no authority to enter into a set-off agreement that sets aside the set-off rules in Chapter 5 of the Bankruptcy Act or the protection of pledgees under the Promissory Notes Act. In that case the administrator could not, with binding effect on the pledgees, accept a set-off that reduced the value of the pledged claim. A well drafted intercreditor agreement therefore not only limits the debtor’s own right of set-off but also narrows the administrator’s scope to accept a set-off that erodes the value of pledged intra-group claims.
A case for the negotiable promissory note
Against this background, lenders have reason to consider carefully whether to accept that a pledged intra-group loan is documented as an ordinary claim rather than a negotiable promissory note. For a pledgee, a negotiable promissory note has several advantages.
- The note carries the right. The claim follows the document, and the pledge is perfected when the pledgee or its agent takes possession of the original (Section 22).
- The debtor has fewer objections. Most defences arising from the underlying relationship are cut off against a pledgee in good faith (Section 15).
- Set-off is the exception. A counterclaim against the pledgor can be used only if the pledgee was in bad faith or the counterclaim is connected in a way that meets the requirements of the Promissory Notes Act (Section 18).
- Payment has to follow the note. A debtor that pays the pledgor without seeing the original risks having to pay again.
- Competing disposals are harder. The pledgor cannot hand the same note to someone else with effect against third parties.
There are practical drawbacks. The original has to be kept safe, a lost note must be cancelled through a court procedure which takes a year during which the relevant balance cannot be the subject of perfected security, and a note suits a fixed loan amount better than a revolving balance or a cash pool. Whether repayments of principal can be permitted must be assessed on a case-by-case basis in light of the requirement that the pledgor be deprived of control over the pledged claim. To the extent such repayments are permitted, they must be recorded on the negotiable promissory note, adding to the handling and administration. Where the structure allows it, the stronger position is often worth the extra handling.
What we leave aside
The value of both a pledge and a subordination can be affected by other circumstances. These include the Swedish Companies Act rules on value transfers in Chapter 17 and on financial assistance in Chapter 21, as well as the rules on set-off and clawback in bankruptcy. We do not address them here, but they deserve a place in the picture when a security package is analysed.
Closing thought
Security over intra-group loans is often seen as a standard item in the security package. The Northvolt question is a reminder that the value of that security depends on three things that can be managed in advance. These are how the intra-group loan is documented, when and how the debtor is notified of the pledge, and how the set-off prohibition and the subordination are drafted.

























