Finansinspektionen Rules Out Capital Relief for Boverket’s Credit Guarantee
In May we wrote that Boverket’s credit guarantee was unlikely to give banks meaningful capital relief. On 18 November 2026 the Swedish Financial Supervisory Authority (Finansinspektionen, SFSA) removed most of the remaining doubt. In two sanction decisions, against Serafim Finans AB and Aros Kapital AB, SFSA found that the guarantee as currently documented does not qualify as eligible unfunded credit protection under the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR).
Our earlier article, Boverket’s Credit Guarantee, Capital Adequacy and the Financing of Residential Construction, concluded that any capital effect would depend on the contractual terms and appeared limited. There are now several decisions from SFSA on exactly that point. This article sets out what they say and what follows from them.
Two Decisions on the Same Day
Both decisions concern calendar year 2024 and both result in a remark combined with an administrative fine.
Serafim Finans AB was fined SEK 10 million (SFSA reference 25-6472), with the breaches linked to Boverket’s guarantee concerning both own funds requirements and the large exposure limit. Aros Kapital AB was fined SEK 17 million (SFSA reference 25-6469), with the guarantee-related breach concerning the large exposure limit.
The decisions follow an investigation that SFSA opened in February 2025 into four institutions that had used the guarantee in their capital calculations.
The two sanctioned institutions took different positions. Aros accepted in substance that the guarantees did not meet the requirements and argued mainly on mitigation. Serafim contested SFSA’s reading of the CRR. The higher fine for Aros reflects that it had received a warning and a fine in December 2023 for partly similar breaches. The Serafim decision also covers a separate large exposure to a foreign insurance undertaking, which is unrelated to Boverket.
Why the Guarantee Fails
SFSA’s reasoning is the same in both decisions and rests on the standard framework agreement between Boverket and the lender, not on the individual loans. Two clauses carry the analysis.
- Clause 9.1 describes Boverket’s undertaking as a simple guarantee (Sw. enkel borgen). SFSA reads this as a subsidiary liability, since the lender must first turn to the borrower. That conflicts with Article 215(1)(a) CRR, under which payment may not be conditional on the lender first pursuing the obligor.
- Clause 10.1 provides for compensation in three situations. These are an enforced sale, another sale at a price approved by Boverket and a debt write-down approved by Boverket. In the first case the loss must be realised before anything is paid, so the timing is open. In the other two Boverket decides when the conditions are met. SFSA concludes that the lender does not control the timing of payment, contrary to Article 213(1)(c)(iii) and Article 215(1)(a).
SFSA supports its reading with EBA Q&A 2014_803 and 2015_2306.
The assessment is the same under the large exposure rules, since Article 399(2) CRR only allows a guarantee to reduce a large exposure if Articles 213 and 215 are satisfied. The Aros decision concerns the large exposure limit alone. The Serafim decision goes further and finds that the institution also fell short of its capital requirements once the guarantees were disregarded.
This is the structure we described in May on the basis of Section 7 of Ordinance (2020:255) on a state credit guarantee for loans for residential construction (Sw. Förordning (2020:255) om statlig kreditgaranti för lån för bostadsbyggande), which ties compensation to the same three events. We characterised the guarantee as closer to an ordinary surety with compensation after the event than to a guarantee that can be called on default. SFSA has now reached the same characterisation and drawn the regulatory conclusion from it.
Arguments That Did Not Succeed
The decisions are as useful for what SFSA rejects as for what it finds.
- The sovereign exemption. Article 215(2) relaxes the requirements for guarantees provided by central governments and certain public bodies. Serafim argued that this also covers Article 213(1)(c)(iii), and that this was the intention behind the amendments that applied from 1 January 2025. SFSA holds that the exemption relates only to Article 215(1)(a) and leaves Article 213(1)(c)(iii) untouched, also under the new wording.
- The 24 month rule. For residential mortgage loans Article 215(1)(a) accepts a guarantee under which the guarantor pays within 24 months. SFSA accepts that the rule can apply in principle, since the framework agreement assumes mortgage lending. It fails because the agreement contains no obligation for Boverket to pay within that period. That Boverket may in practice have paid in time in individual cases is not enough.
- Payment before the end of insolvency proceedings. Serafim relied on NJA 1990 p. 245 to show that payment under a simple guarantee can be obtained before a bankruptcy is concluded. SFSA’s answer is that the liability remains subsidiary.
- An unclear legal position. Both institutions pointed to the complexity of the rules, and Aros to the fact that other institutions had made the same assessment. SFSA does not regard the legal position as unclear in a way that excuses the breaches.
- A State guarantee carries no real risk. SFSA accepts that the guarantees reduce risk. The CRR nevertheless sets specific conditions for recognising that reduction, and those conditions were not met.
What Follows for Lenders
- No capital relief on the current terms. A lender subject to the CRR should assume that Boverket’s guarantee neither lowers the risk weight of the guaranteed loan nor reduces the exposure for large exposure purposes.
- The conclusion is general. In May we said the answer depended on the contractual terms. SFSA’s reasoning is built on the standard clauses of the framework agreement, so in our view it reaches every guarantee issued under that agreement.
- The commercial value remains. The guarantee still transfers credit risk to the State and SFSA says so expressly. What is missing is the regulatory recognition of that transfer.
- Past reliance is not excused. Neither remediation, the complexity of the rules nor the practice of other institutions led SFSA to refrain from a sanction. Institutions that have used the guarantee in their reporting should review their calculations. Aros restored its position through a capital injection and funded credit protection.
- The asymmetry grows. Lenders outside the CRR are unaffected. The imbalance we pointed to in May, between banks and alternative lenders in the financing of residential construction, becomes more pronounced.
What Follows for the Guarantee
In May we argued that the guarantee should be designed so that the protection becomes clearer, more direct and more predictable. SFSA made a similar point in its consultation response of August 2025 on a proposed guarantee for housing in certain municipalities, where it noted that Articles 213 to 215 need to be met for a guarantee to give the lender capital relief.
The decisions now indicate what a redesign would have to address. In our reading two changes are needed.
- The payment obligation must not depend on the lender first pursuing the borrower. For mortgage loans a binding commitment by Boverket to pay within 24 months may be an alternative route under Article 215(1)(a).
- The conditions that leave the timing of payment to Boverket, in particular the approval of a sale price or a write-down, must be removed or reformulated. Article 213(1)(c)(iii) applies independently, so a payment deadline alone would not be sufficient.
Since Section 7 of the Ordinance itself ties compensation to these events, an amendment of the framework agreement is unlikely to be enough. The State does not need to accept a pure on demand guarantee. It does need to decide whether the guarantee is meant to work for regulated lenders, and if so to give the regulatory function greater weight in the design.
Status of the Decisions
Both decisions can be appealed to the Administrative Court in Stockholm within three weeks of receipt and are not yet final. The scope of the sovereign exemption in Article 215(2) is the question most likely to be tested if either institution appeals. Until a court says otherwise, lenders should plan on the basis that SFSA’s view applies.
The question we raised in May was whether Boverket’s guarantee works for the lenders it is meant to support. SFSA has answered that, on the current terms, it does not work in regulatory capital terms. Whether it should is now a question for the legislator.






















